Car finance broker or dealer finance: how to compare the two
A dealer arranges finance through the lenders it has agreements with, at the point of sale. A broker compares loans across a panel of lenders before or while you shop. Either can be suitable; what matters is the total cost and conditions of the loan you are offered.
General information only, updated 19 November 2026. It does not take your circumstances into account.
How each one works
Dealer finance is convenient because it happens where you buy the car, and manufacturers sometimes fund promotional rates on new models. The choice of lenders is limited to the dealer's arrangements.
A broker takes your details once and checks them against the policies of several lenders. That can help where your situation is less standard, such as self-employment, a private sale or an older vehicle.
How each is paid
Both dealers and brokers are usually paid commission by the lender, and either may charge a fee. You are entitled to ask what commission and fees apply to the loan you are offered, and brokers must disclose them in the documents they give you.
Compare offers on the same basis
Put both offers side by side with the same loan amount and term.
- Comparison rate, not only the advertised rate.
- Establishment, monthly and early payout fees.
- Any balloon and the total amount repaid including it.
- Whether a low rate depends on paying a higher price for the car or buying add-ons.
- Conditions on extra repayments and paying the loan out early.
A low rate is not always the lowest cost
A promotional rate can come with a shorter term, a required balloon or less room to negotiate the car's price. Work out the total you would pay under each offer, including the car, before deciding.
Common questions
Moneysmart: car loans (ASIC) ↗Is it cheaper to use a broker or dealer finance?
Neither is always cheaper. Compare the comparison rate, fees, any balloon and the total repaid under each offer for the same amount and term.
Can I use a broker and still buy from a dealer?
Yes. Finance arranged through a broker can be used to buy from a dealer. The lender pays the dealer at settlement.
Do car finance brokers charge a fee?
Some do, and most are also paid commission by the lender. Ask for the fees and commission in writing before you proceed.
Does a 0% or 1% dealer offer have a catch?
Not necessarily, but check the conditions: the car's price, the term, any balloon, and fees. The offer may only apply to particular models.
